Australian Adjudication Report (1906)
Test piece : The Rose of Castille
Not clean at opening : tongues want smartening up very much. From A bass and horns were very bad at tongueing.
A tempo : Soprano had a nasty accident, which did not encourage him very much I am sure.
Andante sostenuto : Horns badly out of tune, bass very much across at bar 8. Horns are very poor from D on. Cornet does well, but is badly supported by band.
Allegro giusto is very moderate. Band is evidently very young at contesting. The rall. bar after G was badly across. I don't think you could have done it worse if you had tried to.
Andante : Trombone sounds very nervous, everthing is too stiff and formal, no life in it.
Allegro : Far too slow and only moderate. Euphonium cadenza very nicely done.
Allegretto moderato : Tenor horn was late at starting. I suppose he thought it did not matter much, he came on later.
Moderato : This was fair, and it was phrased properly : the first band to do it. I compliment you. Cornet cadenza a good show. Allegro too slow.
Lento : Those horns are badly out of tune, Mr. Conductor.
Andante : Fair. Soprano made a moderate attempt, many wrong notes, though. Cornet was very uncomfortable from S to T. From bar 26 to end of movement baritones, trombones and basses were terribly across, so you can imagine what it sounded like. That could be vastly improved by taking each section separately.
Allegro moderato : Euphonium solo was nicely given, but the accompaniments were very scattered.
Finish of selection was very poor, the semiquaver runs being very indistinct.
As I said before, evidently not up to contesting form. But plod on. Nil desperandum.
Marks 92 (out of 150)
Adjudicator : Mr A Wade, Ballarat, Victoria
As printed in the Rockhampton Morning Bulletin, June 19, 1906
This report was originally posted to the Brass Band Mailing list by Graeme Cameron. The band, which is long since defunct, came